Use case B46 · Business
Business owner has four AI models review his company's health benefits contracts, each critiquing the last, until they mostly agree
- Operations
- Beginner
- Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, Grok
- Source checked · X post
The short version
What they did
Cuban puts the PDFs of his company’s health benefits contracts, including the broker or consultant agreement, into one AI model and asks where the terms work against him and what he can do about it. He then gives the same PDFs and the first answer to a second model and asks what the analysis got right, what it got wrong and what it would change. He repeats this across Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini and Grok “till they mostly agree.”
Result (as claimed)
No measured result. Cuban: “They are better than your broker or consultant and can save you money and make sure the contracts are fair.” He posted it as a recommendation and asked others to “Let us know what happens.”
Prompt
First, review the contracts in one assistant:
I own a business and want to understand our health benefits contracts before speaking with our broker. The documents are [attach plan documents, renewal and broker or consultant agreement]. Our main concerns are [costs, renewal terms or other concerns].
1. Identify terms that may work against us. For each, quote the relevant clause and give the document name and page.
2. Explain the concern in plain English, then suggest questions or possible changes to discuss with the broker.
3. Separate clear contract terms from your interpretation and list documents or details you still need.Return a table and a short summary under 300 words. Don’t invent costs, rights or missing clauses. Flag unclear wording for review rather than treating your reading as a legal conclusion.
Then ask another assistant to check the same documents and the earlier answer:
I own a business and am reviewing our health benefits contracts. Another AI has already analyzed them. Check its work independently using the same documents: [attach contracts and broker agreement]. Its analysis is [paste earlier answer].
1. For each main finding, say what the earlier answer got right, got wrong or left unclear. Read the contracts yourself rather than accepting its quotes.
2. Give the document name, page and clause behind each correction, and explain what you would change.
3. List the points you agree on and the questions that remain for our broker or adviser.Use a plain-English comparison table and a summary under 200 words. Don’t invent missing terms or costs. Agreement between models isn’t proof; keep unsupported points open. I’ll repeat this check with other assistants and verify the final list.
Do it yourself
Suggested steps, not the source’s exact setup.
What you need
- Two or more AI assistants that can read PDFs, such as Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini and Grok.
- Your benefits plan documents, renewal and broker or consultant agreement as PDFs.
Start simple
- Gather the plan documents, the renewal, and the broker or consultant agreement as PDFs.
- Run the first prompt in one AI assistant.
- Paste the documents and that answer into a second assistant with the second prompt.
- Keep going until the answers stop changing much. Make one list of the points they agree on.
Take it further
- Ask for the questions to bring to your broker at renewal, ranked by how much money is at stake.
- Ask each model what it would need to see to be sure, and get those documents.
Check your work
- Models agreeing doesn’t make them right. Check every quoted clause against the PDF yourself.
- Take the final list to your broker or a benefits adviser before you act on it.
Source checked. The link, author, date and quote were confirmed against the source. The result itself has not been reproduced. Prompt adapted for this library, inspired by the case. Business size: Not stated. Results are quoted as the source claimed them and never improved. Spot an error or a broken link? Email charlie@cbarmorecpa.com.