Use case #5 · CPA
Do tax research with AI, then verify it before relying on it: a memo drafted in 30 seconds and checked for 45 minutes, and ChatGPT treated like an intern
- Review/QC
- Beginner
- Not stated (generic AI), ChatGPT (paid/professional)
- Source checked · LinkedIn post
The short version
What they did
Two CPAs let AI do the first pass on tax research and kept the checking for themselves.
A tax memo drafted fast, then verified
AI drafts the research memo; Shubham Shandilya verifies every citation and documents the review. His LinkedIn post, 2026-04-11.
ChatGPT treated like an intern
Reuven Rubinson does tax research where ChatGPT must state whether each answer is definitive and give California treatment. He also uses it to convert PDF statements into Excel. His LinkedIn post, 2026-07-05.
Result (as claimed)
The tax memo: “AI drafted my tax memo in 30 seconds. I spent 45 minutes verifying it.”
The intern: ChatGPT conversion “works a lot better” than save-as or copy/paste; tip to re-print to PDF, OCR, and split files over 20-30 pages.
Prompt
Written for this library, one for each example.
Checking an AI-drafted memo:
I’m a CPA preparing to verify an AI-drafted tax memo. I’ll paste [the complete memo] and [any primary-source text already collected]. Help me build a review checklist; I will make the final checks myself.
1. Extract every cited Code section, regulation, ruling and case.
2. Give me a table with the citation as written, the claim it supports, any exact passage supplied, and what I need to check in the primary source.
3. Separately flag uncited conclusions, missing facts and assumptions that could change the answer.Keep the comments short and plain. Mark each citation as checked against supplied text or still unverified. Don’t claim a citation exists or supports a conclusion unless you have read the source. Don’t invent replacement citations or treat this checklist as completed verification.
Asking like you would an intern:
I’m a CPA using you for a first pass on a tax research question. The question is [paste question]. Relevant facts: [paste facts]. The tax year is [year], and I need federal and California treatment. I’ll also supply [any primary-source excerpts or research notes].
1. Identify missing facts that could change the answer and ask me for them.
2. Give federal and California treatment in separate sections, explaining whether each answer is definite or depends on unresolved facts.
3. List the primary authority I should check, with the claim each citation supports.Keep the draft under 500 words in plain English, followed by a short review checklist. Don’t assume missing dates, amounts or elections. Mark anything you cannot verify as unverified and say when you don’t know. I will check the authorities before relying on the answer.
Do it yourself
These steps are my suggested way in, not any one person’s setup.
What you need
- A chat assistant, such as ChatGPT or Claude.
- Access to primary sources: the Code, regulations and your research service.
- A tax question you have already answered, to test with.
Start simple
- Ask your answered question using the “intern” Prompt.
- Compare its answer with yours. Note what it got right and wrong.
- Ask it to draft a short memo on the same question.
- Run the review Prompt on the memo, then check every citation in the primary source yourself.
Take it further
- Save both prompts in a project so every research question gets the same checks.
- Ask for federal and state treatment separately, as Rubinson does.
- Use it to turn PDF statements into spreadsheets. Re-print to PDF and split long files first.
Check your work
- Open every cited section and ruling. Check it exists and says what the memo claims.
- Watch for assumed facts, like a service date the client never gave you.
- You are the reviewer of record. Document what you checked before anyone relies on the memo.
Testing
2026-10-18 (the tax memo example): The draft took 46.086 seconds and the second AI review took 92.457 seconds. Source checks found wrong pinpoints and an assumed service date. Human verification time was not measured. The full run record includes the exact inputs, output, timing and scoring. The source claim remains unverified.
Before you rely on it
- This is general information about how accountants use AI, not professional guidance for your engagements.
- You stay responsible for the work under your professional standards, including review and sign-off. An AI tool’s output is a draft, not evidence.
- Before you send client data to an AI tool, read the tool’s data and training terms, and get any client consent you need. For tax return information, that includes IRC section 7216.
Source checked. The link, author, date and quote were confirmed against the source. The result itself has not been reproduced. Prompt adapted for this library, inspired by the case. Business size: Not stated. Results are quoted as the source claimed them and never improved. Spot an error or a broken link? Email charlie@cbarmorecpa.com.