← All use cases

Use case B24 · Business

Small law firm has Claude check a late document production against its deficiency letter overnight

Graydon Trusler, operations for his wife's law firm, Trusler Legal (on the Lawyerist Podcast) ·

The short version

What they did

Opposing counsel supplemented a document production at 11:30 the night before a hearing. Trusler gave Claude the firm’s deficiency letter and the new production, asked it to report what was still missing, then had it redraft the deficiency letter. He has worked in the operations of his wife’s family-law firm and now also works as an AI specialist for lawyers.

Result (as claimed)

“And in about five minutes I had that” (the report), and then: “And in about 15 minutes I had a complete deficiency letter.” Of his work generally: “I’m doing things in 15, 20, 30 minutes that would’ve taken three or four hours for a paralegal to do.”

Prompt

Their prompt:

here’s the deficiency letter, here’s the production that they just produced. Go through it and verified that they produced everything they asked for and give me a report what’s not there.

since you have the original deficiency letter, just update it, make a new one with what’s missing.

A fuller version to copy, in two steps. First, check the documents:

I work at a small law firm and need to compare a new document production with our deficiency letter. The letter is [attach], the new production is [attach labeled files], and earlier productions to consider are [attach or say none].

1. Make a table with one row for each requested item: request, produced, incomplete, missing or unclear, and the file and page supporting that status.
2. For incomplete items, specify the apparent gap, such as missing dates or pages.
3. List files you couldn’t read and items that need a lawyer’s judgment.

Use plain English and keep the summary under 200 words. Don’t assume an item is absent just because a search found nothing. Don’t invent document references or legal conclusions. I’ll verify the table before using it.

Then draft the updated letter after checking the report:

I work at a small law firm. Draft an updated deficiency letter using our original letter [attach], the document review table [paste], and my confirmed corrections [paste]. The items we have verified are still missing or incomplete are [list].

1. Keep the original letter’s format and professional tone. Remove resolved requests and describe the confirmed remaining gaps precisely.
2. Use only the requests, dates and document references in the supplied materials.
3. After the draft, give a short change log showing what you removed, retained or reworded, and list any questions for the reviewing lawyer.

Don’t add deadlines, threats, citations or demands that I haven’t supplied. Leave ambiguous points open. Produce a draft for lawyer review without sending it.

Do it yourself

These steps are my suggested way in, not Graydon Trusler’s setup.

What you need

  • A chat assistant that can read long PDFs, such as Claude or ChatGPT, on a plan your firm has approved for client files.
  • The original request or deficiency letter, and the documents the other side produced.
  • A lawyer who signs off on anything that goes out.

Start simple

  1. Try it first on a closed matter, where you already know what was missing.
  2. Upload the letter and the production. Paste the fuller document-check prompt above.
  3. Ask for a table: each item requested, whether it was produced, and the page or file name that shows it.
  4. Compare the table with what you already know. Note what it got right and wrong.
  5. Once you trust the method, use the fuller letter prompt to draft the updated letter.

Take it further

  • Use a saved project with your standard letter format and tone.
  • Split very large productions into batches and ask for one table per batch.
  • Ask it to list items that were produced but look incomplete, such as missing months or pages.

Check your work

  • Open the cited page for every “produced” item. A wrong “yes” is the costly mistake.
  • Search the production yourself for two or three items it marked missing.
  • This is legal work with client data. A lawyer reviews and signs every letter, and check your firm’s rules before you upload confidential files.

Source checked. The link, author, date and quote were confirmed against the source. The result itself has not been reproduced. Their prompt is quoted from the source; any fuller version is written for this library. Business size: Not stated. Results are quoted as the source claimed them and never improved. Spot an error or a broken link? Email charlie@cbarmorecpa.com.

More in Operations

New cases go out every Saturday in Inside AI.