Use case P66 · Human
Prime Day shopper asks Alexa for Shopping to compare vacuum deals against usual prices and her own criteria
- Money and shopping
- Beginner
- Alexa for Shopping
- Source checked · blog post
The short version
What they did
christine used the Amazon shopping AI to compare two vacuums, asking it to separate the better product from the better deal and weigh the features she cared about. She changed her prompts to request normal selling prices rather than advertised percentage discounts. She explicitly says she did not independently verify the returned price history and caught contradictory price-difference arithmetic in the answer. She had not decided which vacuum to buy when she wrote the post, so this is a comparison workflow, not a verified savings claim.
Result (as claimed)
“Still don’t know which to buy, but at least I do know more and have developed some better prompting habits.”
Prompt
Their prompt:
Compare as a purchase: Dyson V8 $269.99 vs Shark IZ363HT (HEPA) $199.99. Ignore list-price discounts; compare each to its real street price. Note if they’re different product classes. Score on: price-vs-street 30%, cleaning 25%, runtime 20%, HEPA 15%, upkeep 10%. Answer two things separately: better DEAL, and better PRODUCT. Cite source+date per price or mark unverified.
A fuller version to copy:
I’m choosing between two vacuums and want to separate the better product from the better deal. The exact models and current prices are [model, price and listing details]. My priorities and weights, totaling 100%, are [criteria and percentages].
1. Check each model’s usual selling price rather than relying on advertised list-price discounts. Give the source and date, or mark the price unverified.
2. Compare the features against my criteria and explain if the models belong to different product classes.
3. Show a weighted comparison and give separate conclusions for better deal and better product.Use a concise table and plain words. Show the arithmetic for price differences and explain uncertain scores. Do not invent price history or treat an unverified price as proof of savings. I will check the models and prices before buying.
Do it yourself
These steps are my suggested way in, not christine’s setup.
What you need
- A shopping assistant or chat assistant with web search, such as Alexa for Shopping, ChatGPT or Claude.
- The two or three products you’re choosing between, with today’s prices.
- A free price-history tracker for the store you’re buying from.
Start simple
- Write down what matters to you and give each item a weight. Make the weights add up to 100%.
- Paste the prompt above with your products, prices and weights.
- Ask for the better deal and the better product as two separate answers.
- Ask it to show its math for every price difference.
Take it further
- Add a third option that isn’t on sale, to test whether the sale matters at all.
- Ask for the most common complaints in owner reviews of each.
- Add three years of running costs: filters, batteries, replacement parts.
Check your work
- Check each usual price yourself in a price-history tracker. christine didn’t verify them, and caught the AI’s arithmetic contradicting itself.
- Redo the price differences by hand.
- Confirm the exact model numbers. Similar names often hide different features.
Source checked. The link, author, date and quote were confirmed against the source. The result itself has not been reproduced. Their prompt is quoted from the source; any fuller version is written for this library. Business size: Individual. Results are quoted as the source claimed them and never improved. Spot an error or a broken link? Email charlie@cbarmorecpa.com.