There seems to be a sentiment forming as more and more of our clients start using AI. Most of us are now fielding AI assisted messages and questions from clients, a lot of which are not clear/correct or are derived from missing context that the client’s AI lacks.
The reasons are usually the same: the client’s agent doesn’t have the full context. No final TB. No prior period close. No return. Missing qualitative data that had a quantitative impact. A conversation we had that never got fully documented or recorded by the client. Ultimately an incomplete picture of the full situation.
But their agent answers/advises anyway. Then we spend time explaining why it’s wrong or where pieces of it are wrong or why something is now N/A because of X or the parts that are actually correct.
I don’t believe the move is trying to restrict or discourage our clients from using AI to try and get answers to their questions. I feel like that’ll make us adversarial about something most of our clients are going to do anyway.
I think a better solution is something of a shared room per client. They bring their agent to work in it and we bring in ours.
This way, both of our agents have access to the same context. The up to date financials. The completed returns. The prior workpapers. The actual conversations we’ve had. The stances taken and the reasons for them. Everything an answer would need in order to be right.
Then a straightforward question has a real chance of being answered correctly the first time.
The objection is that this automates us out of a job. If someone’s situation is genuinely simple, they may not need an accountant for much longer. This is fair, but I think this is the direction things are going and I don’t think pretending otherwise does us any good.
Answering questions was never the whole job anyway. The work is knowing which question they should have asked. Catching what they didn’t think to mention. Getting to a transaction before it closes instead of explaining it after. Signing the return and carrying that risk. Signing off on financials so they can get approved for a loan. Standing in front of the IRS when something goes sideways. Amongst many other things. None of that gets easier to hand off just because the answers got cheap.
There’s a lot of unknowns under this shared workspace concept and what the future of our profession looks like as clients and practitioners bring their own agent into the mix. Which makes it difficult to plan for, but I’d rather build the place where a client’s agent gets good answers than spend the next few years explaining why the answer they got somewhere else is wrong.